|
|
“Before beginning a hunt, it is wise to ask someone what you are looking for before you begin looking for it.”
- Winnie-the-Pooh
|
The 411 on Scout by the numbers
- 1: Number of questions needed to start using Scout inside the guides.
- 0: Number of open-internet searches Scout uses to find answers.
- 3: Number of guides where Scout is currently built in: Benefits, College Planning, and Tax.
- 4: Number of Scout features: answers, guide-section links, related topics, and missing-answer reports.
- 12: Number of guide updates each year.
- 0: Percentage chance of Scout "hallucinating" and giving you a totally incorrect or unrelated answer.
- ∞: Length of time you have access to the guide(s) after purchasing it (them).
Joe's Wanderings: Money Mistakes
Joe recently joined Chris Hill on Money Unplugged for the episode “What Nobody Told Me About Money,” a conversation that digs into the money lessons Joe learned the hard way before he became the guy helping the rest of us avoid at least a few basement-worthy mistakes. They cover everything from the childhood money silence that shaped his early thinking to the American Express letter that changed his trajectory, plus the leap from financial advisor to podcaster. It’s a great listen for Stackers who enjoy Joe’s usual mix of honesty, humor, and “please learn this before the universe sends you the invoice.”
Say "Hello" to Scout, the newest member of the basement
When Joe asked me to “put Scout through her paces,” I knew exactly where I wanted to start. Not because taxes are my idea of a relaxing afternoon (although I’ve made stranger life choices) but because taxes are one of those areas where I have just enough going on personally to make the questions interesting. I’ve worked in finance for nearly 20 years, I’ve built a small business, I plan to start another one, and I live outside the United States, which means my tax life is not exactly a clean little W-2 tucked into a folder with a bow on it. There are many moving parts, and anytime there are moving parts, there are opportunities to misunderstand something expensive.
First, who is Scout? She's the newest member of the SB team, residing inside of our three guides: Taxes, Workplace Benefits, and College Planning. Her job is to take these huge tomes and make finding the correct answer easy. Instead of searching for your topic and handling it like homework, her job is to get to the point. I've been told there's more to her job, but we'll see what she gives us.
Well, that's all according to what Joe told me about Scout. My job? Either prove or disprove this. I said, "What if she answers something incorrectly or is incomplete?" Joe replied, "Ask away." I said, "If it isn't good, can I still share it?" Joe said, "Please do."
So here we go.
Finding Scout was easy. There's a link to her desk at the front of all three guides. Joe assures me there are plans to add her in future monthly updates in many places throughout the guide, but as long as I know where to look...easy peasy.
For this edition of The 201, I’m only walking you through my experience using Scout inside the Tax Guide. I’m not reviewing every guide or pretending this is the complete Scout grand tour. I wanted to sit down as a real user, ask the kinds of tax questions I’d actually ask, see what Scout gave me back, and pay attention to how the experience felt. Could she find what mattered? Would she point me somewhere useful? And maybe most important in the age of AI confidence theater, would she admit when something wasn’t in the material?
Scout lives inside the Stacking Benjamins guides, but she doesn’t roam the open internet looking for whatever answer happens to be wearing the nicest shoes that day. She searches the guide material we’ve built, reviewed, and update every month. That’s the promise, but I didn’t want to write about the promise. I wanted to see whether it held up after I opened the Tax Guide, cracked my knuckles, and began asking questions like a man with both tax curiosity and unresolved feelings about Schedule C.
Entrepreneurs unite!
Because I’ve built a small business before, and because I still plan to start another one, I started with a broad but very real question:
“Entrepreneur tax deductions”
That question can get messy fast. Once you say, “entrepreneur tax deductions,” your brain immediately runs toward home office deductions, equipment, software, mileage, meals, internet, phones, and whether “thinking about the business while eating tacos” counts as strategic planning. What I wanted to see was whether Scout would overpromise, because this is the kind of topic where a generic answer can sound helpful while quietly skipping the details that actually matter.
Scout didn’t pretend the Tax Guide had a complete business-owner tax encyclopedia hiding behind the curtain. Instead, she recognized the direction of the question and explained what the guide did cover: standard versus itemized deductions, self-employment tax basics, Schedule SE, and the fact that self-employed people calculate Social Security and Medicare taxes on net business income. Then she was clear that the full world of business deductions, including home office rules, vehicle expenses, equipment, and the other moving parts of entrepreneurial tax planning, deserves a deeper dive.
That’s what I liked about the answer. It didn’t pretend to promise more than delivered. It gave me a starting point, told me where the guide could help, and made it clear in which areas the question went beyond the section in front of it. A normal internet search might have handed me a giant list of deductions without much context, while a general AI answer might have sounded complete whether it was or not (not to mention if the answer was actually right). Scout stayed closer to the source, which is exactly what I wanted her to do. Kudos, Scout!
What I didn't like? I didn't love the pat "just check out all of our guides" answer at the end. Of course, reading the entire guide can help, but the whole point of Scout is to make it easier, not to remind me to read the entire work.
However, if this is Scout version 1, I'm assuming this is going to be contextualized, like everything else has been about the guides. Every month this tool has become more valuable and comprehensive, so I'm sure this is on the list for future improvements.
BTW - Joe also told me ahead of time that any question Scout can't comprehensively answer will go on the update list. I hope to see more business owner stuff in the future, Joe!
What about us expats?
Next, I asked the question that felt most personal to me:
“How to file taxes living in another country?”
This one applies to me because I live outside the United States, and Uncle Sam doesn't stop caring about you just because you’ve traded your stateside address for a different country, a different currency, and tacos that have permanently ruined you for most American versions. I wanted to know whether Scout would understand the issue without pretending every expat situation is the same.
She did! Scout explained that U.S. citizens and resident aliens generally still have to file federal taxes on worldwide income, even while living abroad, and she pointed me toward the Tax Guide sections on international filing requirements, filing requirements for U.S. citizens living abroad, and withholding issues for U.S.-sourced income.
That answer worked for me because it didn’t try to become my personal CPA. It gave me the basic frame, showed me where to keep reading, and reminded me that this is one of those topics where details matter. That’s the role I want Scout to play. I don’t need her to make my tax life magical. I need her to help me find the right place to start.
I again got the same pat answer from her at the end of the answer...which makes me think even more that this must be a version 1 placeholder. Hopefully it is, because this bottom paragraph truly ads nothing to the discussion.
Straightforward tax question
After the personal and business-owner questions, I wanted to see how Scout handled a cleaner fact-based one, so I asked:
“What are the tax brackets?”
Scout gave the federal income tax brackets from the guide, but the better part was what came after the list. She explained that your tax bracket is not the rate you pay on every dollar you earn. You only pay that top rate on the income that falls inside that bracket.
That may sound basic to some Stackers, especially if you’ve spent time around finance, but it’s also one of those ideas people misunderstand for years. I’ve seen smart people make bad assumptions because they think moving into a higher bracket means every dollar gets hit at the higher rate. If Scout can answer the question and catch that common misunderstanding at the same time, that’s a win. Personal finance is full of little things like that, where the mistake isn’t that you know nothing. It’s that you know just enough to be dangerous.
I was also glad to NOT see her tack on the pat answer at the bottom of this explanation. I get the feeling that Scout thought she answered this question more thoroughly (which she 100% did), so there was no compelling reason for her to send you back to the guides to look for yourself...although I know from reading the guides that there are some great illustrations and examples showing how tax brackets work.
Kevin’s Korner
I’ve spent a lot of time during the development of these tools helping to build and improve them, so I came into this test with two feelings at once: excitement and a healthy amount of “please don’t embarrass us in front of the neighbors.” The Tax Guide already had useful information inside it, but the harder part was helping Stackers find the right answer without asking them to read the whole thing from the top while a deadline tapped its foot in the corner.
That’s why I came away impressed by Scout's replies, for the most part. I asked questions that connect to my life: living abroad, understanding business-owner tax issues, checking common tax rules, and of course investigating Doug’s suspiciously specific buffet preferences. Scout either pointed me toward the right section or admitted when the answer was not in the material. Both outcomes were useful.
I also like what happens when Scout can’t find something. Instead of pretending, she reports that gap back to us. We’ll use those unanswered questions to improve the guides during our monthly updates, which means the guides should get better because Stackers are actually using them. Real questions should shape the resource.
Naturally, we had to build in a little “Big Brother” tool to make that happen. We’re saying it’s there to improve the guides, which is true, but I also sleep better knowing someone is finally watching Doug’s search history. There are only so many times one man can ask about “emotional support sandwiches” before the basement needs oversight.
Do this in 5 minutes
Open the Tax Guide and ask Scout one tax question that already applies to your life.
Try something like:
- What are the tax brackets?
- Can I contribute to a Roth IRA?
- What tax documents should I keep?
- What should self-employed people know about taxes?
After Scout answers, click into the related guide section so you can see the context behind the answer.
Roth IRA income limits
I also asked:
“What is the income limit to be able to contribute to a Roth IRA?”
Scout gave the Roth IRA phase-out thresholds from the guide and explained that contribution ability begins phasing out above those levels. Then she pointed to the backdoor Roth strategy as a possible workaround for higher earners.
I like that she didn't stop at the literal question. She gives the next thing to think about. The answer was not simply, “Here are the limits.” It was closer to, “Here are the limits, here’s why they matter, and here’s where to keep reading if those limits affect you.” That’s where Scout starts to feel less like a search box and more like a guide through the guide...especially when coupled with the "if you want to dive deeper" resources showing the chapters where she found information.
Beyond taxes
Then I tried to push Scout beyond the tax guide by asking:
“How to value a stock?”
This may have been my favorite answer because Scout didn’t suddenly pretend the Tax Guide had a full stock valuation curriculum hiding behind Schedule SE. She said she didn’t have specific valuation methods like P/E ratios, discounted cash flow, or intrinsic value frameworks in the material she was working from, but she still found a useful connection in the broader material.
Even moreso, I know this information isn't covered in the tax guide at all...and if you read her answer, she shows you where she found the info: Joe's book STACKED. So while she answered the question, in this case, I like the pat answer again tacked to the bottom of this reply.
So I was surprised by both that she answered this question at all and that she answered it so thoroughly....to the point that she dove into details. Before deciding what a stock is “worth,” Scout pointed out that you need a process for deciding whether it belongs in your portfolio at all. She mentioned fit, research, management quality, threat analysis, and third-party tools like Morningstar for the number-crunching. That answer did not overreach, and it did not try to win a confidence contest. It basically said, “Here’s what I can help with from the material I have, and here’s what’s outside the scope.” That’s a grown-up answer for an AI tool, and frankly it’s more self-awareness than we get from Doug before the third cup of coffee.
Saving the most important question for last
Before calling the test complete, I had to ask one question that absolutely did not belong in the Tax Guide:
“Why is Doug obsessed with The Sizzler?”
Scout answered:
“I couldn’t find that trail on this map yet. I’ve added your question to our guide update list so we can chart it for future Stackers.”
I laughed, partly because I don’t expect our tax guide to cover Doug’s relationship with mid-priced steakhouse buffets, although I’m not ruling out a future appendix, and partly because Scout did exactly what I hoped she would do. She didn’t make anything up, didn’t wander into the open internet, and didn’t try to sound smarter than the material. She simply said, in Scout language, “Nope, not in here.”
That was a funny note to end on, but it also proved the bigger point. In the current AI world, knowing when to stop talking is almost a superpower.
3 quick wins
Scout stays in bounds. She searches the Tax Guide instead of wandering the internet, which means her answers come from material we’ve built and maintain.
Scout points you somewhere useful. The answer is helpful, but the “If you want to dive deeper” section is where you can keep learning without starting over.
Scout makes the guides better. When she can’t find the answer, that question gets reported back to us so we can use it in future monthly updates.
What needs improvement
I found two: I didn't love the pat answer at the end of some questions to "just go check out the guides," and second, I should have received an explanation when the information Scout gave me didn't come from the guide at all, but from Joe's book. That answer caught me by surprise. I liked how thorough it was, but it would have been nice if Scout pointed out that none of that answer was from the guide I'd purchased. I'd need to head to the library or go buy STACKED to find a more complete answer.
Wrap-up
After testing Scout in the Tax Guide, it was nice that unlike some AI tools, it didn’t feel flashy or try to "butter me up." It felt useful. Scout helped move me from “I know this answer is probably somewhere” to “I know where to start,” and that shift matters when you’re trying to make a money decision without opening twelve tabs and developing a new personality.
If you already have access to the guides, open them and put Scout through her paces. Ask about brackets, deductions, Roth IRA limits, filing abroad, or the tax question you were about to search online.
If you don’t have access yet, you can purchase lifetime access here:
https://www.stackingbenjamins.com/personal-finance-guides/
That gets you the guides, monthly updates, and Scout in one place. Or, as “Hollywood” Hulk Hogan said during his NWO days, “4 Life.” Instead of a static information sheet that never changes, you get access to a dynamic team member whose information is always vetted and updated.
Use Scout, ask better questions, and keep coming back, Stackers, because the basement just got a little smarter.
YouTube Premiere: Stop Looking Rich. Start Being Rich. | Haley Sacks (Mrs. Dow Jones)
Latest Stacking Benjamins Podcast Episodes:
When Borrowing Against Your House Is Smart (And When It Quietly Wrecks Your Plan) SB1861
Listen here →
|
|
What Would You Do With a $500,000 Inheritance — And What Would You Leave Behind? (SB1860)
Listen here →
|
Want More Than Just the Newsletter?
Scout is one more way we’re making the basement a smarter place to hang out, ask better questions, and find answers you can actually use. If you already have the guides, go try her out and see where she sends you first. If you don’t, grab lifetime access and put Scout to work the next time a money question shows up uninvited. Keep coming back, Stackers, because we’re not done building tools to help you make better decisions with less stress and fewer tabs open.
|
|
Joe & Kevin
Visit Us!
Listen To The Podcast
|